Former India captain and coach Anil Kumble expressed strong disappointment over India’s dismal showing against South Africa, describing it as an “abject surrender.” He criticized the team for making excessive changes to the playing XI and the batting order, which disrupted consistency and balance.
“You can’t have so many allrounders, so many changes, so many changes in the batting order, so many changes in the team,” Kumble said while analyzing India’s loss.
Kumble highlighted that the frequent experimentation with player roles and line-up combinations affected rhythm and confidence. He emphasized that successful teams maintain a stable core and make thoughtful adjustments instead of constant reshuffles.
He also noted that India’s fielding and bowling strategies lacked clarity and execution, further compounding their struggles. Kumble stressed the need for a defined game plan and accountability within the squad.
“It’s very disappointing to see such inconsistency at the international level. Players need time to settle in their positions,” he remarked.
Kumble urged the management to establish a clear selection policy centered on balance and role clarity. According to him, performance in key moments defines the outcome of a series, and India’s inability to maintain composure under pressure contributed to their downfall.
The defeat against South Africa, he said, should serve as a lesson for India’s think tank to restore focus, stability, and strategic clarity before future tours.
“You need to trust your combination and back players to deliver instead of chopping and changing every match,” Kumble concluded.
Author summary:
Anil Kumble sharply criticized India’s chaotic team selection and lack of stability in their series against South Africa, calling it a major factor behind the disappointing defeat.