If you grew up in the mid to late 2000s, you likely had a crush on a young Josh Hutcherson. He gained fame as the “first crush” in family films like Zathura, Bridge to Terabithia, and Journey to the Center of the Earth, before starring in The Hunger Games series.
Now 33, Hutcherson appears in the 2025 HBO comedy I Love LA, playing the boyfriend to Maia, portrayed by creator and star Rachel Sennott, known for leading the Bottoms cast in 2023.
When asked by Bustle if he’s ready to reclaim his internet boyfriend status, Hutcherson laughed and admitted to not knowing he ever held that title:
“I had no idea I ever had such a title.”
The term “internet boyfriend” refers to a celebrity widely admired online and often idealized by fans. Recent well-known internet boyfriends include Pedro Pascal, Jeremy Allen White from The Bear, Jonathan Bailey from Bridgerton—who was also named “sexiest man alive”—and many co-stars of Daisy Edgar Jones.
During the interview, Hutcherson was seated next to his I Love LA co-star Leighton Meester, sharing a lighthearted exchange about the topic.
Note: HBO Max subscription plans start at $10.
Author's summary: Josh Hutcherson reflects on his unexpected “internet boyfriend” fame while starring in HBO's I Love LA, blending nostalgia with a fresh comedic role.